So this is gonna be not as in depth as it could be b/c of one reason. That one reason is that Red is the worse album she's released under Universal. I hate to say this b/c I LOVE Beni and her music but this album ain't it. Now it's not horrible but it is lacking. I did appreciate the fact she wanted to do things a lil differently but it was meh. The main issue was the production! She worked with a totally different producer for this album than she usually does. The new producer, can't remember his name, to me didn't seem to know how to work with her voice. Beni's a good singer (fab alto tone), but range is limited so she can't do many vocal acrobatics and get up there like May J, Utada, Crystal Kay, etc. can. Sweet Danger is soooo bad. I couldn't deal with the production at all! It was a mess. Ugh. I liked 7 tracks out of the 13 and they were: Reasons, Early Summer Rain, Red, Home Sweet Home, 2:00 AM, Our Sky, and Sand of Time. The other 5 were just a mess.
So in summary the biggest flaws with this album was the production and Beni's vocals at times (due to the production).
Overall I give it a 7/10. This album was just underwhelming and not consistent. Kudos to her wanting to be a lil different but personally I hope next album she goes back to D.I., Lil Showy, HIRO, and 3rd Productions. They really know how to work with her beautiful voice. She can try different things with them while also getting a nice production and nice vocals.
Update: Beni's album was #7 for the 1st week with only 10k sold. This is her lowest 1st week sales under Universal. Look it's really time to re-evaluate things. Beni had a strong yr in 2012, with her two cover albums. Covers 1 has sold over 200k and Covers 2 had sold 140k (anything over 100k or over = success) so for her to go from this to this is tragic. I know Japan loves their cover albums but it makes no sense for her original material not to sale,especially after her successful 2012 yr. I was expecting Bitter and Sweet/ Lovebox numbers to be honest. Out of all her original albums the only successful one was Bitter and Sweet. That album sold over 100k. Look at Che'Nelle she released an Japanese album that sold only 4,500k , then released a covers album that sold over 350k, then released a second original Japanese album that went to sell over 200k. So yeah this is an issue for Beni.
From Jpopcentral - Official Beni Thread:
mh honestly, nah no way she could have sold that much with basically no promo involved. They promoted COVERS heavily once they realized it had potential, but quite frankly, there is basically nothing around to let you know the girl is releasing a new album. Unless you go to Tower Record or Tsutaya Shibuya, or Lumine Est Shinjuku, the promo is nowhere to be found. Even JASMINE had more promo all over Tokyo with HERO playing all day long and a few posters here and there LOL. That's sad but she had no appeal with this album, no leading track, no physical promo. They didn't even try to play the COVER GIRL card which makes me believe they didn't even care.
I would say 10k is pretty decent considering the situation. At least she made the top 10, it's already something lolLet's see if it'll have some longevity but I wouldn't count on it. I'm not usually pessimistic but I'm gonna be realistic now that I've actually seen from my own eyes the extent of her non-existant promo lol
Well there u go. Universal do better!!!! Beni gurl it's time to get a new team. Ughh I want her to be bigger so bad. I wanna see her sells for her original material to do fab, I wanna see her perform in stadiums (not them same concert halls she's been doing since 2010), I want to see her on variety shows, I want her to become an household name! She's beautiful inside and out. She deserves all the good things. You know I expect 2 things to happen in the future: A Covers 3 (lawd I know I know), and a drastic change in her music. She has to do something b/c staying like this ain't gonna work. Best of luck to Beni. Hopefully next time will be her jackpot. I'll always be a fan :)